Match of the Day pundits Joe Hart and Alan Shearer have criticised the handball decision that went against Chelsea forward Morgan Rogers during his side’s 4-1 defeat to Leeds United in the Premier League. Both former players argued that Rogers did not make himself bigger with his arms and suggested the referee should have been given another look at the incident.
The disagreement highlights ongoing debate about how officials interpret handball law, particularly the “making the body bigger” criterion that has divided opinion across the league this season.
KEY FACTS
- Joe Hart said he wished the referee had the opportunity to see the handball decision again
- Alan Shearer disagreed with Morgan Rogers being penalised for handball
- Pundits stated the Chelsea forward “didn’t make himself bigger” with his arms
- Chelsea suffered a 4-1 defeat to Leeds United in the Premier League
- Both analysts appear on BBC’s Match of the Day programme
What the pundits saw differently
Hart, a former England goalkeeper, and Shearer, the Premier League’s all-time leading scorer, reviewed the incident together on Match of the Day. Their assessment centred on whether Rogers’ arm position constituted an offence under current guidelines. The laws instruct officials to penalise a player whose hand or arm makes their body “unnaturally bigger” — a phrasing that has produced inconsistent application since its introduction.
Both men concluded that Rogers’ arms were in a natural position for a player moving at speed and contesting a ball. Shearer emphasised that the forward was not attempting to block a cross or shot with an extended limb. Hart added that the speed of the incident made real-time judgement difficult, reinforcing his view that the referee deserved a second look via video review.
How did we get here?
The handball decision came during Chelsea’s heavy loss at Elland Road. Leeds United’s 4-1 victory moved them clear of the relegation zone while leaving Chelsea’s European qualification hopes dented. Rogers, a summer signing from Middlesbrough, has featured regularly under Enzo Maresca but found himself at the centre of controversy in a match where his side were already trailing.
Handball law was rewritten in 2019 to remove “intent” as a factor and focus on whether the arm position made the body unnaturally bigger. The International Football Association Board (IFAB) clarified the wording again in 2021, but Premier League referees continue to interpret the threshold differently from week to week. Pundits and managers have repeatedly called for greater consistency.
WHAT WE KNOW — AND WHAT WE DON’T
Verified by the source:
- Joe Hart and Alan Shearer criticised the handball call against Morgan Rogers
- Both pundits stated Rogers did not make himself bigger with his arms
- Hart specifically said he wished the referee could see the incident again
- Chelsea lost 4-1 to Leeds United in a Premier League fixture
- The discussion aired on BBC’s Match of the Day programme
Still unconfirmed:
- Which specific match minute the incident occurred
- Whether the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) reviewed the decision
- The identity of the on-field referee or VAR official
- Whether Chelsea has formally contested the decision
- How the decision affected the match scoreline at that moment
WHY IT MATTERS
When high-profile former players publicly question a key handball decision, it amplifies pressure on refereeing bodies to clarify guidance. Inconsistent application undermines confidence among players, coaches, and fans. The Rogers incident adds to a growing file of cases where the “unnaturally bigger” test appears to produce different outcomes for similar actions, suggesting the current framework still leaves too much to subjective judgement.
WHAT TO WATCH
Premier League referees’ body PGMOL may issue guidance or a clarification if similar incidents arise in coming matchweeks. Any formal response from Chelsea or the league would signal whether this case prompts a review of current interpretation standards.