Israel’s Supreme Court ruled on Tuesday to limit National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir’s authority over senior police appointments, delivering a blow to the far-right politician’s attempts to reshape law enforcement leadership. The 8-1 decision requires police commissioner nominations to be approved by a cabinet committee, effectively removing Ben-Gvir’s unilateral control.
The case stemmed from Ben-Gvir’s controversial push to install allies in top policing roles since taking office in 2022. Analysts note the ruling reinforces institutional checks on ministerial power. “This maintains the professional independence of police leadership,” said a former justice official speaking anonymously due to the sensitivity of the matter.
Ben-Gvir, leader of the Jewish Power party, had argued the police portfolio traditionally granted appointment powers. But petitioners including the Movement for Quality Government successfully contended that unchecked ministerial authority could politicize law enforcement. The court agreed, citing “exceptional public importance” in maintaining oversight.
The decision comes amid heightened tensions over judicial reforms and follows Ben-Gvir’s failed attempt to fire the police commissioner last year. Some coalition members warned the ruling could destabilize the government. “This judicial activism undermines democratically elected officials,” argued Likud MK Eli Dalal in a statement.
Legal experts suggest the precedent may affect other ministries’ appointment powers. With Ben-Gvir vowing to challenge the decision through legislation, the stage is set for renewed clashes between the judiciary and Israel’s right-wing coalition government.